|
|
|
|
![]() |
|
|
Managing alcohol withdrawal in hospitalized patientsTherapy includes benzodiazepines to reduce withdrawal symptoms and prevent delirium. Symptom-driven protocols may be more beneficial than scheduled-dosing plans.Zachary Hartsell, MPAS, PA-C; Jennifer Drost, MMSc, PA-C; James A. Wilkens, MD; Adriane I. Budavari, MDThe authors practice in the Department of Hospital Internal Medicine, Mayo Clinic Hospital, Phoenix, Arizona. They have indicated no relationships to disclose relating to the content of this article.![]() Alcohol is currently the second most abused drug in the United States and is abused by up to 9% of the population.1,2 Approximately 11 to 15 million people report heavy alcohol intake, and the costs of medical complications related to alcohol abuse in the United States are estimated to be almost $100 billion per year.2 Although many definitions of alcoholism exist, the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism (NIAAA) classifies women who consume more than 7 drinks per week and men who consume more than 14 drinks per week as being at high-risk of progressing to alcoholism. More than 4 drinks a day is considered heavy alcohol use for women, more than 5 drinks a day for men.3 Heavy alcohol users are at risk for withdrawal symptoms, with hospitalized patients who abuse alcohol at greatest risk. Some reports suggest that at least 25% of general medical inpatients have alcohol use disorders.4 In trauma patients, the rate is much higher, with alcohol dependence or abuse present in 25% to 47% of these patients.5 In a study of 242 trauma patients admitted to a suburban US hospital, 43% were found to have elevated blood alcohol levels and 33% were legally intoxicated.5 The incidence of patients with alcohol withdrawal syndrome is projected to be nearly 2 million per year, with more than 500,000 per year having withdrawal symptoms severe enough to require pharmacologic treatment.6 Even though alcohol withdrawal is a common inpatient disorder, studies suggest that many hospitalized patients are not receiving appropriate diagnosis or treatment. Bostwick and colleagues found that in an urban Level I trauma center, approximately 75% of alcohol abusers were identified.7 Despite this, only 43% of these patients had withdrawal prophylaxis ordered, and only 38% were monitored for alcohol withdrawal signs and symptoms.7 This article reviews the pathophysiology of alcohol withdrawal, describes how to evaluate and monitor patients potentially suffering from this condition, and suggests treatment strategies. PATHOPHYSIOLOGYAlthough the exact mechanism of action for alcohol withdrawal is unknown, the GABA inhibition theory is the most widely accepted. Alcohol enhances the inhibitory chloride influx mediated by gamma-aminobutyric acid alpha (GABA-A), resulting in clinical sedation. With chronic alcohol use, tolerance develops and GABA receptor function is downregulated. Alcohol also inhibits the excitatory N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) receptor, thus diminishing the excitatory effects of glutamate and, over time, increasing neuroexcitatory tone. Finally, alcohol causes alpha2-receptors to inhibit norepinephrine release. As a result, when alcohol is abruptly withdrawn, the unopposed hyperexcitable neurons cause the symptoms of withdrawal.8 Another key pathophysiologic concept in alcohol withdrawal is the phenomenon of kindling. Kindling begins as a single electrical stimulus initially causing no overt clinical manifestations but eventually results in the appearance of abnormal behavior (such as seizures) when the stimulus is administered repeatedly. Applied to alcoholism, kindling explains why each episode of alcohol withdrawal appears to increase patients risk of withdrawal symptoms. Chronic alcoholics typically experience progressively shorter intervals between their last drink and onset of symptoms, as well as progressive worsening of symptoms during each subsequent episode of alcohol withdrawal.
CLINICAL PRESENTATIONThe signs and symptoms of alcohol withdrawal fall along a spectrum, ranging from mild and self-limiting to life-threatening (see Figure 1). Importantly, these signs and symptoms should be attributed to alcohol withdrawal only after other medical conditions are considered and ruled out. Minor withdrawal The manifestations of mild alcohol withdrawal typically start between 5 and 10 hours after the last drink. This early stage of alcohol withdrawal is characterized by mild autonomic hyperactivity, manifesting as tremulousness, mild anxiety, tachycardia, hypertension, GI upset, insomnia, and vivid dreams. Since the signs and symptoms of alcohol withdrawal are quite nonspecific at this stage, the diagnosis can often be missed. Symptoms of minor withdrawal typically resolve spontaneously in 24 to 48 hours, with or without treatment. Major withdrawal Major withdrawal syndromes tend to occur approximately 48 to 72 hours after the last drink. They include alcoholic hallucinosis, alcohol seizures, and delirium tremens (DTs).
First characterized in 1989, alcoholic hallucinosis occurs in an estimated 10% to 25% of hospitalized alcoholics.9-11 Hallucinations can be tactile, visual, or auditory, but patients with alcoholic hallucinosisunlike those with DTsmaintain a clear sensorium.6 Although definite risk factors for alcoholic hallucinosis have not been identified, a study of 643 patients in a Veterans Affairs drug and alcohol treatment center found that those who developed alcoholic hallucinosis were younger at the onset of their alcoholism and tended to be heavier drinkers than alcohol abusers who did not.11 Alcoholic seizures occur in up to 10% of patients suffering alcohol withdrawal. They tend to occur 24 hours after the last drink but can occur even while alcohol is still measurable in the blood. Alcoholic seizures are single, short, generalized tonic-clonic seizures that can recur successively but rarely progress to status epilepticus.9 Status epilepticus, focal seizures or seizures associated with fever or known head trauma, and seizures starting after the patient becomes delirious are not typical of alcohol withdrawal and require further workup. DTs is considered the end point of the alcohol withdrawal spectrum and represents a medical emergency. DTs occurs in approximately 5% of patients with alcohol withdrawal.6 Symptoms typically start 48 to 72 hours after the last drink and include confusion, disorientation, impaired attention, severe autonomic activity, and hallucinations. A history of DTs, a long history of sustained drinking, age greater than 65 years, concurrent medical comorbidities, and seizure activity during the present admission are risk factors. Earlier studies found mortality in patients with DTs to be as high as 20% even with treatment, but more recently mortality is cited at about 1%, with death generally occurring from arrhythmias or concomitant illnesses. When DTs is unrecognized and untreated, mortality can exceed 35%.12 EVALUATING THE PATIENTThe first step in evaluating the hospitalized patient with suspected alcohol withdrawal is ruling out other medical conditions that could be causing the signs and symptoms. When alcohol withdrawal remains likely, key historical information includes total duration of alcohol use, daily quantity of alcohol ingestion, elapsed time since last drink, history of alcohol withdrawal syndromes, abuse of other substances, and history of major medical and/or psychiatric conditions. The physical examination should not only focus on identifying the signs and symptoms of alcohol withdrawal but should also attempt to uncover any signs of complicating medical conditionsincluding (but not limited to) arrhythmias, heart failure, liver disease, pancreatitis, or infections. Once alcohol withdrawal syndrome has been diagnosed, the severity of the episode should be determined since severity will guide further therapy. Although most patients undergoing alcohol withdrawal need close observation, some warrant admission to an ICU. These include patients with advanced age; hemodynamic instability; hyperthermia (persistent temperature higher than 39°C/103°F); a severe electrolyte disturbance or acid-base disorder; moderate to severe cardiac, pulmonary, or renal disease; active infection; rhabdomyolysis (as evidenced by an elevated creatine kinase [CK] level combined with a normal CKMB/troponin level); or prior DTs or withdrawal seizures.13 Preventionthat is, trying to identify which patients are at high risk for alcohol withdrawal before they become symptomaticis considered the best practice. Although patients may be reluctant to discuss their drinking, the interview remains the most reliable and accurate means of assessing alcohol intake and determining who is at risk for withdrawal. Although validated only in the outpatient setting, the CAGE questionnaire can also be a useful interview tool for assessing inpatients suspected of alcohol abuse. It is comprised of the following four questions:
The CAGE questionnaire has an overall sensitivity of 85% and a specificity of 89%; with three positive answers, its sensitivity is 100%.14 The main disadvantage of the CAGE is that it does not distinguish between past and present alcohol use, and it therefore does not provide any information about the current status of the patient with respect to alcohol withdrawal syndrome. The CAGE questions are designed to elicit information about alcohol abuse in hopes of identifying patients most at risk for withdrawal; therefore it is most appropriate to use during the admission interview, before the withdrawal symptoms begin. Laboratory results that may indicate alcohol abuse include elevations in mean corpuscular volume (MCV), gamma-glutamyl transpeptidase (GGT), and liver transaminases. Elevated liver transaminases with the pattern of AST being more than 2 times higher than ALT is the most common laboratory finding in patients who abuse alcohol. One study noted this finding in 83% of patients admitted with alcoholic hepatitis.15 Additionally, this pattern is generally not seen in other forms of liver disease.15 GGT is commonly measured to determine chronic alcohol use but has a sensitivity of only 30% to 40%.15 GGT can be elevated in patients with nonalcoholic forms of liver disease or in those taking certain medications. An elevated MCV is an index of RBC size. MCV increases with excessive alcohol intake after 4 to 8 weeks. The mechanism of the elevation in chronic alcoholism is unknown, but the elevation is found in 90% of alcoholics. Patients who binge drink or who have started drinking heavily only recently (within 90 days) may have normal-size RBCs.16 In more recent studies, elevations in carbohydrate-deficient transferrin level was shown to be a more sensitive and specific biologic marker for detecting alcohol abuse, but testing for this is impractical in the hospital setting.17 DETERMINING SYMPTOM SEVERITYIn patients with suspected active alcohol withdrawal, the Clinical Institute Withdrawal Assessment for Alcohol scale, revised (CIWA-Ar), is the best tool to determine severity and to guide therapeutic intervention (see Figure 2). The CIWA-Ar is well-validated and has high reproducibility and reliability.18 The CIWA-Ar was created to assess and guide treatment of acute alcohol withdrawal. It also has utility in triage. For example, patients with a CIWA-Ar score of less than 10 can be observed and in some cases may be treated as outpatients, as long as they have a stable living situation with close follow-up and no history of relapses or major comorbid mental or medical illness.19 Patients with a CIWA-Ar score greater than 10 should be admitted for inpatient treatment and close observation. Patients with a CIWA-Ar score greater than 15 will need initiation of treatment with benzodiazepines. After being used as a triaging tool, the CIWA-Ar can be used to guide therapy and monitor for worsening of the withdrawal.18 Unfortunately, few clinicians report routinely using the CAGE questionnaire or the CIWA-Ar with patients. According to Friedmann and colleagues, although most clinicians ask patients if they consume alcohol, only 13% report using a validated screening tool such as the CAGE.20 In addition, the CIWA-Ar is rather labor-intensive, requiring high levels of nursing care to administer effectively. However, without validated tools, diagnoses of alcoholism and alcohol withdrawal are delayed, as are necessary treatments.
TREATMENTTreatment goals for alcohol withdrawal syndrome include alleviating symptoms, preventing progression to DTs, controlling underlying comorbidities, and initiating rehabilitation.9 Supportive care Treating a patient in alcohol withdrawal includes providing a quiet environment with supervision and precautions against falls. Electrolyte abnormalities should be corrected, but routine administration of magnesium has not proved effective.21 Similarly, IV fluids should be reserved for patients with signs of excess fluid loss. Finally, a daily multivitamin (orally if possible) and thiamine (100 mg by convention) are generally recommended, though formal evidence to support these interventions is lacking. A recent Cochrane systematic review found insufficient evidence from randomized controlled trials to guide clinicians in the optimal dose, route, frequency, or duration of thiamine for prophylaxis against or treatment of Wernicke-Korsakoff syndrome.22 Pharmacologic therapy Pharmacologic treatment of alcohol withdrawal centers upon using medications that are cross-tolerant with alcohol. Benzodiazepines are considered first-line therapy. Their mechanism of action is to enhance the depressant neurotransmitter GABA and replace the effects of alcohol. A review of 57 trials with a total of 4,051 patients found that the risk of alcohol withdrawal seizure was reduced with the use of benzodiazepines compared with placebo.23 Although no specific benzodiazepine has been shown to be superior to another, certain agents are recommended, based largely on their pharmacokinetics. For example, long-acting agents such as diazepam and chlordiazepoxide effectively prevent rebound symptoms. In patients who are elderly, have hepatic disease, or are critically ill, intermediate-acting agents like lorazepam or oxazepam are preferred to prevent oversedation. Lorazepam and diazepam are available for oral, IV, and IM administration, whereas chlordiazepoxide and oxazepam have only oral formulations.24 Clonazepam, temazepam, and alprazolam are not recommended. Fixed-dose versus symptom-triggered regimens An influential randomized controlled trial by Daeppen and colleagues inspired a major change in how benzodiazepines are administered to hospitalized patients experiencing alcohol withdrawal syndrome. This study compared symptom-triggered benzodiazepine therapy (administering a dose in response to symptoms) versus fixed-dose (administering a fixed dose at standard intervals regardless of symptoms) therapy. The CIWA-Ar was used to measure the severity of the withdrawal, and an appropriate dose of benzodiazepine was given based on the score. In the 117 patients studied, symptom-triggered dosing showed no difference in comfort levels. However, the mean duration of treatment was shorter in the group treated in response to symptoms (20 hours vs 63 hours), and there was a marked decrease in the mean quantity of medication administered (37 mg vs 231 mg). There was no difference in complications between the two groups.25 IV ethanol (IVE) historically was used for the treatment and prevention of alcohol withdrawal. Discussion of its use was confined to case reports, whose authors felt IVE to be less sedating than benzodiazepines.26 A 2004 review of anecdotal reports of IVE in critically ill patients with alcohol withdrawal similarly found no evidence to support its use.27 This conclusion is a result of IVEs inconsistent pharmacokinetic profile, relatively narrow therapeutic index, and enhancement of drug interactions secondary to hepatic metabolism.27 Adjunct medications Benzodiazepines are considered first-line therapy for alcohol withdrawal syndrome, and adjunct medication should be used only in conjunction with benzodiazepines. Beta-blockers and alpha-blockers have been traditionally used in the management of alcohol withdrawal, particularly to treat hypertension. The purpose of beta-blockade in alcohol withdrawal is to reduce the result of increased cardiac autonomicity, including arrhythmias and increased cardiac output. Adjunctive therapy with beta-blockers should be considered in patients with known coronary artery disease. Alpha-blockers, such as clonidine, work similarly to decrease sympathetic tone and affect mainly the alpha-receptors.24 Historically, anticonvulsants have been widely used to control alcohol withdrawal symptoms (particularly seizures). Carbamazepine is used widely throughout Europe for outpatient treatment of alcohol withdrawal. It appears to suppress the kindling effect and to decrease the craving for alcohol after withdrawal.9 A 2005 review of 48 studies found the use of anticonvulsants controversial. Because of the heterogeneity of agents available and the limited studies performed, no recommendation could be made on their use for alcohol withdrawal. When compared to benzodiazepines, anticonvulsants had equal efficacy in preventing seizures but a worse side effect profile.28 Additionally, studies have shown no effect on arresting the progression to DTs.9 Neuroleptics are often used to treat agitation and hallucinations in alcohol withdrawal syndrome. In 2004, Mayo-Smith and colleagues published a meta-analysis of nine prospective controlled trials which culminated in the formation of an evidence-based practice guideline for the management of alcohol withdrawal delirium.29 They suggested that sedative-hypnotics are more effective than neuroleptic agents in reducing duration of delirium and mortality, with a relative risk of death when using neuroleptics of 6.6, though the confidence interval was very wide (95% CI, 1.2-34.7). Importantly, the nine trials cited were decades old (1959-1978), occurring when diagnostic criteria were less clear and older neuroleptics were used. In contrast, other practice guidelines have recommended haloperidol as first-line therapy for delirium including alcohol withdrawal delirium.30 In the absence of clear research evidence demonstrating their efficacy and safety in treating alcohol withdrawal, antipsychotics such as haloperidol should be used with caution. In low doses, haloperidol can treat agitation and hallucinations, but it has no effect on autonomic dysfunction. Additionally, antipsychotics theoretically can lower the seizure threshold, as well as place hypomagnesemic withdrawal patients at risk for torsades de pointes.6 Finally, baclofen appears to be a promising new therapy for alcohol withdrawal. Baclofen is a GABA-B receptor agonist. In several small studies, it reduced moderate and severe symptoms in alcohol withdrawal syndrome, and it had a more favorable side effect profile than benzodiazepines. Furthermore, baclofen exhibits less addictive properties and may be more effective than benzodiazepines at helping to maintain abstinence in alcoholics.31,32 Before widespread use of baclofen can be recommended, however, larger studies comparing it directly to benzodiazepines are needed. Treatment after hospitalization Ensuring proper follow-up is one of the key steps in effectively managing patients with alcohol-related disorders. Long-term abstinence should be the goal, and the process can start with a brief intervention from the provider. For example, a brief bedside intervention may play a major role in helping patients achieve the long-term goal of total abstinence. A large meta-analysis of 32 controlled studies looking at the impact of brief interventions on drinking behaviors found that brief intervention was superior to no intervention, and some studies found brief intervention was as effective as extensive therapy.33 Although inpatient psychiatry consultation is not mandatory for every patient, it should be considered for those with withdrawal symptoms resistant to treatment, those with comorbidities or multiple substance intoxications, and those with a co-existing psychiatric disorder. Every patient should be offered counseling services either as an inpatient or as an outpatient. Additionally, the intervention of social workers and a case manager is essential to ensuring proper follow-up of the patient. DRUGS MENTIONED Alprazolam (Alprazolam Intensol, Xanax) REFERENCES
|